Consider This - Chuck Palahniuk
If you think you can hang, this book has a lot to teach you.
Tone - A frank, funny, shocking conversation with a friend who is constantly pushing the envelope with what is socially acceptable to say.
What - A mix of excellent writing advice and retrospective on Palaniuk's career. Good advice both ways but full of his trademark shock value
Who - writers looking to increase the impact of their work on their readers
Read it When - before or during revisions
% on Topic - medium to high depending on if you want to do book tours or not.
This is the second review in two months that starts with a caveat. And this is a big one. If you are easily shocked, disturbed, or find yourself ruminating on terrible things you've read long past when most others have moved on. Don't read this book.
This text contains some intentionally shocking awful things used as illustrations of his experiences and rhetorical points and they are not confined to specific sections that you can skip. In fact, they make many of his points vividly clear and effective. If you think you can hang with serious harm to animals, harm to authors, blood, drug use, alcohol, necrotic gore (no really) and worse, then this book has a lot to teach you. If you don't, well I'm going to put some of my reading notes under the review again and I'll do my best to pick out the good bits.
You know Chuck Palaniuk as the man who wrote Fight Club. That may be the only thing you know about him. He's written nearly a dozen other books and short story collections all of which feature "stories you can't unread" - the subtitle of one of his short story collections and a good summation of his work overall. He claims to write in the "minimalist" school, and his spare prose is often cited as part of the general appeal of his otherwise shocking works.
That said, the tone of this book is warm and friendly. Palaniuk frequently presages his advice with "If I were your teacher" "If you were my student" I'd ask you... I'd say to you... I'd recommend you.. I forbid you .." which gives it an intimate and far more engaging tone than other writing books. It's an enjoyable and informative read with a ghoulish, dark sense of humor that shines through the entire text.
While this is certainly a writing book, it is also a memoir of Palaniuk's time on the road. The writing text is interspersed with "Postcards from the tour" which are short personal anecdotes from his life. They serve as a kind of object lessons about dealing with sudden fame and living a writing life. And they are worth reading, especially if you hope to be famous one day.
The book is also interspersed with charming tattoo designs of quotes from other authors interspersed through the book: "Under the pretense of thanking them, I stalked them. Stone came to Portland as part of a panel discussion about Zelda Fitzgerald. When I met him at the Heathman Hotel he told me, “For anything to endure it must be made of either granite or words.” These range from silly to profound, but I found it an excellent way to distill the advice of the "sages" he'd met along the way.
The writing advice here is top notch, inject it straight into you veins good stuff. If it wasn't for the parts that made me lead off this review with a big old content warning I would be recommending it to everyone I know. He starts with ways to give your writing texture. More than a dozen things to do, or not with succinct, and funny explanations for all of it. And its like that the whole way through from Establishing your Authority to Tension to Process to Why Bother. It's a book I'm going to be quoting at other writers for years.
So, if you don't mind rolling the dice and taking a bit of psychic damage, this book has a lot to teach you. And if you'd rather not drag your mind through that, my notes on the Textures chapter are below the fold and can be seen by subscribers. I'll try to get the rest together for another post in a few weeks.
If you'd like to buy this book based on this review, please consider using this affiliate link here to help support the site.
Hi again friends, sorry this is only one chapter of notes. Like I said, this book is dense with info and I ran out of time/energy to summarize the whole thing. Let me know if this is the kind of thing you'd like to see more of in the comments. Hard to know if it's worth the energy otherwise. ~EM
Textures
- Think of a story as a stream of information. At best it’s an ever-changing series of rhythms. Now think of yourself, the writer, as a DJ mixing tracks.
- There are many textures of information and a writer needs to be in control of them and how they mix
- An author should switch between POV's as needed to create the effect they want, not often, but not be confined to one POV at a time
- Big Voice vs. Little Voice - "The camera is little voice. The voice-over device is big voice. Little voice (also called Recording Angel because it seems to hover and watch) depicts the moment-by-moment action. Big voice comments on it. Little voice remains objective, giving us the smells, sounds, flavors, textures, and actions in a scene. Big voice muses. Little voice gives us the facts. Big voice gives us the meaning—or at least a character’s subjective interpretation of the events." Make sure you are using both objective little voice and the subjective big voice to give commentary to your work. Very few stories last long in either one or the other, there needs to be a balance of both.
- Specifically recommends starting with little voice predominating, then in the second scene or chapter hitting the reader with big voice.
- A small amount of big voice goes a long way.
- use attribution tags (he said, she said) to create a beat of "nothing" or silence. Since the reader skips over it it creates space between dialogue. Or to control the delivery of dialogue, like the pause before a punchline.
- Create tension by having your character's words contrast with their gestures or actions.
- dialogue is your weakest storytelling tool.
- make a list of wordless gestures 50 or more, so that you always have something for a character to be doing when they are speaking.
- Use repetition to hide the seams between topics - repitition as seam filler. Especially repition of imagery of "catch phrases" of characters. He cites "The first rule of..." in Fight Club as an example of this.
- Use lists as a montage to pass the time. Cities, meals, whatever is relevant.
- Or, when you jump back from a flashback you don't need to come back to the same scene
- Intercut between characters, especially as each character is about to face an obstacle. This seriously drives the reader forward!
- Switch between big and little voice to move time forward. See especially the chapter variation in Grapes of Wrath.
